Afternoon Tea at The Pierre New York

Photographer: Sally Scott
High Tea at The Pierre New York - supplied image
High Tea at The Pierre New York - supplied image

Step back in time and indulge in a classic afternoon tea at the iconic and luxurious The Pierre Hotel New York.

What could be finer than afternoon tea in an iconic hotel, on the Upper East Side opposite Central Park in New York? Afternoon Tea at The Pierre Hotel is an event, tea is taken in the luxurious lounge and Executive Pastry Chef Michael Mignano creates magical sweet treats and world-class scones to be savoured.

At The Pierre, Afternoon Tea is served in Two E Bar & Lounge, originally the Gentleman’s Library when the hotel opened in 1930, today the lounge welcomes Upper East Side locals and travellers to the refined Neoclassical designed lounge, featuring a rotating collection of local artwork and regular cabaret and jazz nights. The Pierre has welcomed many famous faces over the years including Coco Chanel, Audrey Hepburn and Elizabeth Taylor and continues to attract a sophisticated clientele today.

High Tea at The Pierre New York - supplied image
High Tea at The Pierre New York – supplied image

We settle in to a cosy corner of the lounge and are presented with three Afternoon Tea menu options – a Traditional Tea Service, Royal Tea Service with an upgrade to Taittinger Champagne and unlimited Royal Tea Service with free-flowing Champagne for 1.5 hours. In addition, The Pierre also offers special Tiffin & Tea service as a nod to Taj’s Indian heritage.

Our trio opted for the Royal Tea Service with choice of tea with sandwiches, scones, pastries and Taittinger Brut or Rosé Champagne. The Afternoon Tea stand arrived laden with goodies and we were joined by Executive Pastry Chef Michael Mignano to talk us through his creations.

Mignano is a passionate chef, keen to share his food journey and philosophy with fellow foodies. It is evident Mignano genuinely loves what he does and his enthusiasm still shines through despite joining The Pierre twenty years ago as the hotel’s youngest Executive Pastry Chef at 23. Mignano has also gone on to co-author the bestselling cookbook “The Pastry Chef’s Little Black Book” and won the Iron Chef Rooftop Showdown competition against 29 of the cities leading chefs.

During his career, Mignano undertook a research trip to England, where he spent time with the chefs at London’s Dorchester Hotel to learn the art of making scones. The result, scone perfection! Mignano wants the Pierre Hotel scones to taste as fresh as possible despite the scale of production in a busy hotel and that’s why they are firstly made by machine and then hand finished to create that just made flavour and texture.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by High Tea Society (@highteasociety) on

Mignano says Afternoon Tea at The Pierre “is an experience; it’s the service, the aroma of tea and scones, the blending of savoury and sweet, creating theatre and a complete experience to be enjoyed.”


Starting with the tea sandwiches, the whole selection is pleasingly bite size and delicious including Miniature Lobster Rolls. The highlight was the Catskill Smoked Salmon on Rye Bread with Balsamic Onion and Sour Cream with the artisanal bread a standout. Also the Spiced Chicken Tartlet with subtle Indian flavours hints at how spectacular the Tiffin & Tea would be.

Next we come to the main event, Mignano’s famous Freshly Baked Cranberry Scones, served with Devonshire Cream, Raspberry Preserves and Lemon Curd. The scones really are superb, certainly the best we’ve tasted and you can recreate this greatness at home, as each guest is gifted a recipe card with the secret recipe.

Finally, the sweet selection with ten pastries including Linzer Cookie, Coffee Opera Cake, Fresh Fruit Tartlets, Strawberry and Coffee macarons and more. Each tiny morsel has been perfectly executed and is a triumph.

The service doesn’t quite rise to the same heights as the food and we would have preferred to see clothed tables to complement the Rosenthal Fine Bone China and plush setting. The extensive tea selection of green, black and herbal teas by Palais des Thes includes The Pierre Blend, a custom blend of fine black tea spiced with green cardamom, pink peppercorn, cloves, cinnamon, ginger & orange zest.

The atmosphere is convivial, the setting exquisite and the afternoon tea selection exceptional and one to be savoured on your next visit to New York City.

Afternoon Tea at The Pierre New York Menu:

High Tea at The Pierre New York
High Tea at The Pierre New York

Tea Sandwiches

  • Miniature Lobster Rolls
  • American Caviar on Buckwheat Blinis
  • Catskill Smoked Salmon on Rye Bread,
  • Balsamic Onions & Sour Cream
  • Spiced Chicken Tartlet
  • Deviled Eggs on Brioche with Red Sorrel
  • English Cucumber with Dill Cream Cheese
  • Portobello, Brie & Red Pepper Wraps

Freshly Baked Scones

  • Cranberry Scones with Devonshire Cream, Raspberry Preserves & Lemon Curd


  • Fresh Fruit Tartlets
  • Strawberry Lemon Pavlovas
  • Red Cherry Financiers
  • Single Origin Chocolate Cupcake
  • Coffee Opera Cake
  • Strawberry Macaron
  • Coffee Macaron
  • Linzer Cookie
  • Chocolate Crunch Cookie
  • Walnut Cream Cheese Sables

Selection of Tea Leaves

  • Green Teas – Sencha Superior, Grand Jasmine Chun Feng, Icy Mint
  • Black Teas – The Pierre Blend, The Des Lords, Big Ben English Breakfast, Mararets Hope, Saint James, Traditional Chai
  • Green & Black Teas – The Guan Yin Imperial, Rotunda Blend
  • Herbal & Red Teas – Garden of Dreams, Chamomile Apple Spices, Tropical Garden


High Tea New York
– find more experiences in
our High Tea Venue Directory.

The Pierre New York:

2 E 61st Street New York 10065


Available daily from 2.00-6.00pm


Traditional Tea Service $69 USD per person
Royal Tea Service $84-$89 USD per person
Unlimited Royal Tea Service $120 USD per person

Prices are correct at the time of publishing, but subject to change. Please contact the venue for further details.

Sally Scott

Sally Scott is the curator and founder of and freelance travel writer. Alluxia a luxury travel website devoted to connecting style conscious travellers with luxury travel experiences. Sally is a lover of good food, great wine and is in a constant state of wanderlust.

Articles by Sally