High Tea at Mary Eats Cake Melbourne

Photographer: Michelle Milton
Mary Eats Cake
Mary Eats Cake

Mary Eats Cake is a high tea experience curated by two specialist culinary talents in Brunswick, Melbourne.

What happens when you bring together two passionate food and beverage connoisseurs?

You are taken on a gastronomic journey filled with characterful tea infusions and delightful unique sweet and savoury treats with a story.

Sarah de Witt and Jessica Hillbrick
Sarah de Witt and Jessica Hillbrick

Meet Sarah de Witt, the Tea Sommelier behind Impala & Peacock artisan teas and French trained pastry chef, Jessica Hillbrick. The pair met over a Bridal magazine shoot in 2016, and after sharing tea and cake, and their mutual love and appreciation for High Tea, joined forces to bring you this wonderful new High Tea experience in Brunswick, Mary Eats Cake.

The name plays on Marie Antoinette’s famous ‘let them eat cake’ and the experience definitely reflects the fun-loving, down-to-earth, indulgent only sometimes health-conscious alter ego of Mary in all of us.

The gorgeous terrace with French-esque décor and whitewashed exposed brick walls is filled with vintage teaware, flowers, cute quotes and multiple photographic opportunities. The venue also boasts lovely upstairs rooms that can booked exclusively for that perfect bridal or baby shower, birthday or group special occasion, at no additional charge for 12 people or more. They also offer an extensive gluten free/ vegan option that all would be envious of.

Jessica Hillbrick from @maryeatscake talks us through their high tea menu.

A video posted by High Tea Society (@highteasociety) on

High Tea starts with a palette cleanser of Mary’s signature blend of black tea, roses, calendula and cornflowers. Once the palette is prepared it is time to tackle the beautiful Royal Albert bone china three-tier stand of savoury and sweet selections.

The savoury medley is paired with Brunswick Breakfast Tea and the sweet assortment with Mint Variation Tisane, an infusion of peppermint, spearmint, lemongrass, lemon, verbena, lemon balm, lemon myrtle and provincial lavender.

We started with the roasted pumpkin, raspberry and beetroot dip, rocket and goats cheese spinach bread sandwich. Its bright and distinctive colours made it look more like a sweet but absolutely fulfilled our savoury cravings. The buffalo mozzarella, macadamia nut pesto and sun-dried tomatoes on crostini was a delightful treat followed by a tomato quinoa salsa with mozzarella and basil on a crispy polenta base. Finally the warm mushroom, leek and three-cheese quiche, was an excellent savoury finale with its pastry crust full of melted cheesy flavours.

High Tea at Mary Eats Cake
High Tea at Mary Eats Cake
High Tea at Mary Eats Cake
High Tea at Mary Eats Cake

When it came to the tasty homemade fluffy scones, they were topped with jam and fresh cream dolloped with cute little spoons from their eclectic vintage wares.

I was very excited to start to work my way through the sweet selection. The chocolate, mint and matcha opera cake was a piece of bright green art and a combination I had not seen in a High Tea. The cake flavours were each strongly unique however perfectly complimented each other. The salted lemon meringue was a light citron flavour with the shortest of crusts and was followed by the fresh seasonal fruit tart of berries, which was the perfect way to end a gorgeous combination of different yet strangely familiar treats.

High Tea at Mary Eats Cake
High Tea at Mary Eats Cake
Savoury selection
Savoury selection

You can clearly see in the presentation and detail of their charming High Tea that Sarah and Jess are passionate. Both speak of the importance of sourcing local produce with diary ingredients from Jonesy’s Dairy Fresh, free-range eggs from South Gippsland, butter from King Valley Dairy, on the banks of the King River, fruit locally sourced in Brunswick and Meredith Goats Cheese, ensuring the flavours are abundant and local support is strong.

As the tea is blended in Brunswick by Impala & Peacock, make sure you ask about the different flavours available. They have a wonderful selection each with their own unique story, such as Coconut Mint, a refreshing sweet treat that unites the comfort of sweet cacao, refreshing peppermint, soothing calendula, and fun loving coconut. Or the Guyokuro Green, a rare and strong Japanese green tea held in high regard for its potent health benefits where the tea plant is shaded before harvest to increase the natural antioxidants and chlorophyll colour contributing to its umani tones. Each tea card gives you the degrees, minutes of infusing and steeping instructions for optimum flavour. An experience in itself.

If you love fabulous flavours and enjoy a creative twist to your traditional high tea then this is a must. With a friendly team, happy to chat through their creations and new menus launching each season, it is one to put on your bucket list, sooner rather than later, in 2017.

Mary Eats Cake Gluten Free/ Vegan High Tea Menu:

  • Macadamia and basil pesto on roasted potato and cauliflower pattie with sundried tomato
  • Beetroot, roasted pumpkin, rocket, and vegan cheese
  • Crispy polenta with quinoa capsicum salsa and basil
  • Mushroom caps filled with caramelised eggplant
  • Cacao and macadamia chocolate truffle
  • Lychee and raspberry chia seed pudding
  • Chocolate, mint, and matcha raw slice
  • Fresh seasonal fruit tart


Exclusive Tea Rooms – minimum of 12 guests

Mobile Mary:
The complete high Tea experience with food, tea, vintage teaware, flowers, service staff brought to your home or venue of choice for a minimum of 20 guests.


Mary Eats Cake is featured in our Best High Tea in Melbourne list.

Mary Eats Cake Brunswick:

558 Sydney Road, Brunswick, VIC, 3056


All High Teas must be pre booked and they run on:
Friday 2:30pm
Saturday & Sunday 11am or 2:30pm
Monday 2:30pm


Regular High Tea $43pp - including artisan teas
Gluten free/Vegan High Tea $49 – including artisan teas

Ad ons:
A glass of Champagne - $9pp
Blooming Tea - $1.70pp
Macarons - $2.20pp
Take home gift - $8pp
Cheese and fruit degustation - $5pp

Prices are correct at the time of publishing, but subject to change. Please contact the venue for further details.

Aisha Hillary-Morgan

Born in Australia and raised by Dutch parents who ran an international publishing business, experiencing the world, its different cultures and documenting it along the way, was in Aisha’s blood. After 15 years of travelling as a communications professional in retail, media, food, film, entertainment and tech, living in both the UK and Australia, it was time to create Hills & West. In 2015 Aisha left her corporate career and travelled to 50 destinations in 105 days carting a self designed backpack prototype. The Morgan Collection was born and now she collaborates with local artisans, designing bags and sharing the stories of the people and places that inspire her. From the beginning the Hills & West mission has been simple - do what we love, create exceptional pieces, share stories and make people happy along the way.

Articles by Aisha